In the end, which company actually does a better job upholding their warranty and standing by their product? average size) just for the upgrade. Would you please correct the mistake so that your good resource can be even better. In your opinion, is Owens Corning – Duration worth $9,000 cost more than Timberline Hd for the roof? That is about $2900 – 3450 in materials (and Home Depot gets about 30% off the list price on materials). Landmark IR shingles should be installed in areas that get a lot of hail storms. The main difference between Landmark and Landmark Pro is color contrasts, it not much heavier. If you plan on getting the upgraded warranty with labor coverage for either product, it is very important to make sure that your contractor fills out and submits the warranty application. If you had the choice between Owen Corning and Certainteed, which would you choose and why? If you live in areas prone to high winds, ice dams, or heavy rains, we strongly recommend installing only the highest quality underlayment. One disadvantage is that the extra weight makes for a more challenging, time consuming installation. Solaris shingles are designed to be cool, and offer a solar reflective value of more than 40%. If the granules come off, these UV rays will destroy the shingle very quickly. I was able to do so easily by being a certified Master Elite contractor for GAF for three years. One factor that will greatly impact how long your roof will last is the quality of installation. Truth be told, Timberline’s warranty and wind coverage wins out here plain and simple. Some roofers find that GAF shingles shed a lot of these granules literally right out of the box, where as Certainteed products don’t seem to have this problem during installation. GAF and Certainteed have comparable quality shingles. The classic Landmark shingles line has 16 colors to choose from. The Landmark Premium hingles are higher quality than the Landmark PRO. This means that your color availability isn’t as limited by the quality tier, which can be nice. Doing all this will make the process much easier and more likely successful in case you ever need to file a claim. So, you take your roof seriously, which means you also take your roofing materials seriously, right? Lastly, Landmark Premium is about 6.5% more expensive than Timberline HD Ultra. PS – Out of all synthetics, I only recommend DeckArmor, because it’s breathable. Charcoal and Slate are very popular options. I would like to get the thicker, heavier and nicer looking of the 2. In terms of material and installation prices, Timberline and Landmark shingles cost about the same. GAF vs BP vs IKO vs CertainTeed vs Owens Corning- Which one is best?! Review: "STAY AWAY FROM GAF" Shingles installed in late '98. the highest grade is the premium…in the Landmark series. The best metal roof you can buy. More homework needs. Still, many roofers have their personal preference. It is also a good idea to ask the pros who will be providing your roofing estimate, which shingles perform best in the area where you live. Also, Certain Teed and Owens Corning both have a shingle by the name of Driftwood. What information should be in contracts with roofers? 3) try to get several quotes for a metal roof. Brand Focus: GAF Timberline HD® and Ultra HD® Shingles April 17, 2017 by John Zatwarnytsky Homecraft® has helped our neighbors make their homes more beautiful, comfortable, and energy-efficient since 1981. There is no definitive answer. Your email address will not be published. A step up are Timberline HD shingles, available in 14 colors. CertainTeed Landmark® shingles is a prototypical design for a dimensional roof shingle. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and there is no objective way to judge which shingles look better. What Is The Average Lifespan Of A Commercial Roof? Are they in fact the same shingle? CERTAINTEED: The CertainTeed Corporation in North America carries more than 300 roofing options. When it comes to asphalt shingles, i think that basic architectural shingle is the best, and all the premium shingles are a waste of money, unless you really like the way it looks. We believe that the GAF warranties are more secure. Most roofers find that GAF has the best underlayment product. , Leo B incorrectly identified the middle and higher grade of Certainteed Shingles. Comparatively, Timberlines have a narrow line of only 1/16 inches that a roofer needs to be able to nail the shingles to. While we see the difference shrink when we get to the highest-end products, Timberline by GAF clearly is more affordable at face value. It’s a high profile cap that uses 3 separate layers that don’t have to be bent out of shape to get them apart. Each manufacturer has three product lines of different quality grades. Some last as little as 5 years and that is considered normal. We recommend that you ask your contractor how many nails per shingle he uses; 6 nails per row gives the Very Best protection against high winds. However, just like anything else under the sun, each of these brands has advantages and drawbacks. 2) stay away from big brand names (Home Depot, Lowe’s, Sears, Costco, etc) … they all operate the same way: use a big sub to handle all sales / installations, and then this big sub, hires small local subs, while customer pays double. Have you given your roof much thought, as a homeowner? You don’t want to be taught by immediate experience that your roof can’t handle it! So, which is the absolute winner? In terms of pure facts, Landmark shingles weigh at least 250 – 270 lb per square. Like that one for my new roof! In case of shingles, and if you specifically discussed number of nails, it should definitely be in contract. In this case, the decision should come down to choosing between roofers bidding for the job. These none-breathable synthetics trap moisture between roof sheathing and underlayment, which overtime can cause rotting of the roof deck. Pro Tip: hire the contractor who offers the best labor warranty, and has the best references. So the place is half 8$$$.00 of Home Depot. Is that a reasonable thing or should I insist on 6 nail. This makes them about 30% more heavy than Timberlines. However, if you want to have a more comprehensive warranty, GAF and Certainteed require that the installation is done by their certified contractor. One of the biggest factors that can sway a homeowner toward one product over another is curb appeal. CertainTeed Landmark Shingles, is this a good price or is this too high. You don’t necessarily need to get up on the roof and watch him nail the shingles, but it is important that he realizes that you are there. Is all levels of the landmark shingles the same color? Well I have asked several GAF representatives. timberline ns vs hdz, Asphalt Roof Shingles: GAF vs Certainteed Part of a roofer’s job is to guide the consumer in brand choices. If you’re not sure what this data means for you, fill out our contact form today, we’ll happily help you apply these findings to your own decision making! All shingles have these small granules on the outside. Basic roof shingles cost about the same. See costs in your area GAF vs CertainTeed: Final thoughts Keep in mind that when it comes to the durability and quality of your roofing, installation is just as important as materials. These are both regarded as the crème of the crop, so to speak. Doing this may void your “premium” warranty (it does not affect the basic material warranty). After Cedar Impressions® Polymer Shingles were unanimously approved by The Philadelphia Historical Commission, this was the first time that a designated National Historic Landmark was clad in #CertainTeed Cedar Impressions. Wind damage is not an installation warranty issue… same can be said about ice dams, but preventing ice dams is more in the hands of contractors (using proper materials, can minimize or prevent ice damages all together). All others will trap moisture and make your plywood rot. Stay away. They’ve been around for 40 years. Also updated pricing to current levels. Back to contract – put all specifics in it. There comes a point when being excessively cheap is just foolish, and can end in you spending more money in the long run, but if you’re ready for GAF or Certainteed, which are high-end brands, you’ve already accepted some level of higher expense, right? These are the shingles which are most often installed by DIY homeowners, since they are available at most local Home Depot locations. For most people, the cost is the bottom line, and that’s fair, within reason. They have been tested to withstand the impact of a 2 inch steel ball dropped from 20 feet in the air. 1) get several quotes from GAF & CertainTeed certified roofers. Different roof system components have various pricing, depending on their quality. This is HIS responsibility. Jul 15, 2019 - This board contains pictures of homes that we roofed using GAF Timberline HD and HDZ shingles in the color Slate. Certainteed Landmark vs. GAF Timberline shingles: which roof looks best? Felt is better, because it won’t cause rot. This is the most popular line for GAF and in fact this is the Number 1 architectural shingles sold by volume in the US. Landmark Pro are 32% more expensive than Timberline HD. However, that won’t cover if the wind damage, ice damming, etc.. In other words, these are pretty equal, and it’s kind of unpredictable here. Also, remember that the color you see on the sample board that your roofer brings will differ from what it looks like when it covers the entire roof. Thus, if too many are lost, your original roof color will change. He typically prefers the way it installs and has had no complaints about it form previous customers. Folks - I am down to the wire here and need to pick one shingle. Another point of contention is how much and how quickly shingles from these two brands shed their surface granules. This can be one of the reasons why some less experiences roofers would not like Certainteed shingles. The most popular colors here are Williamsburg slate and Weathered Wood. Nature has this thing about perpetually trying to decimate any structure humanity builds. There is the chance that neither of these is the ones right for you, and one of the other high-pedigree brands out there may instead be more ideal. There is a weight spec available for the CT and it 235 lb/sq, but no thickness available. I also got one quote for metal roofinf, but not sure, the price is about 6$$$ more then GAF HD. When it comes to protecting your shingles from wind blow off, correct installation is critical. Best overall shingle: CertainTeed, Landmark PRO Best overall value: BP, Everest 42 Best algae resistance: Malarkey, Highlander CS BEST Shingle Adhesion: BP, Everest 42 BEST Nailing Area: Malarkey, Highlander CS GAF TL What Roof Material Is Most Durable and Long Lasting? Thus, it is better for you to actually be home during the install, and make sure that the roofer you hire is doing a proper job. GAF Timberline and Certainteed Landmark shingles, A post shared by GAF Roofing (@gafroofing), Roof Replacement Or Roof Repair: How To Determine If You Need A New Roof. Educate yourself about real shingle prices, and the difference between basic vs. high-end products, so that nobody will take advantage of you. Both manufacturers DO NOT cover damages due to: hurricanes, earthquakes, mold and mildew, acts of war, floods, tornadoes, other natural disasters, discoloration caused by fungus or all types of algae (except blue-green variety), cracks or movement in the roof deck, animals and animal feces, leaks due to ice dams. Also, it is a good idea to have a back up color, just in case you cannot have your first choice. Moreover, the granules are painted to create different colors. He will be able to do a far better job than someone who either has never installed it before, or does not think its a quality shingle. Some premium shingles may have a non standard color variation – however, they are still mostly similar / the same across different line of shingles. Timberline ® UHD Shingles will cost you just pennies-a-day more than standard architectural shingles. A post shared by GAF Roofing (@gafroofing) on Mar 20, 2019 at 9:10am PDT, Project highlight: Sedgeley Club Boathouse of Schuylkill River Boathouse Row. Typical inland installation is 4 nails (not 5) and in increased wind uplift areas (along the coast, etc) it is standard to use 6 nails. We depend on the sun for life, yes, but the sun is also a giant nuclear fireball, and this means it’s forever belching out intense heat and UV radiation. This is an especially important question for people who live in harsh climates, where there is excessive heat, or cold, ice dams, high winds, frequent rains, severe temperature fluctuations. Along the coast, you do need 6 nails. GAF specifies that if you want to extend your warranty coverage for wind blow off from 110 mph (standard) to 130 mph, shingles need to have 6 nails. Damage, ice damming, etc 100 vs what was originally quoted and lines... “ slate-looking ” asphalt shingle – most likely GAF slateline estimate form to find local contractors the public some! Of siding colors and styles ” asphalt shingle – most likely GAF slateline of that... Pro Tip: not every color you see in either the GAF are... Natural Shadow has 8 colors last a long time trying to decimate any structure humanity.! Certainteed offers wind uplift coverage: Certainteed offers wind uplift coverage only the! T cause rot sought-after being GAF Timberline vs. Certainteed Landmark shingles & Certainteed certified roofers to go too! To decimate any structure humanity builds product Certainteed standard laminate shingles weigh of Wilmington North! Chart of how much each of these products, Timberline and Certainteed Landmark in Moire and... They offer several distinct advantages find out that you can actually get it where you.... It really should not cost you just pennies-a-day more than 300 roofing.. Laminate shingles weigh upholding their warranty and standing by their product product that is sq. Come off, high quality, economical breathable synthetic underlayment, called Deck Armor sturdy. Which averages to about 100 square feet of 7360.00 variety of quality for the novice in what some shingle-related mean! The reasons why some less experiences roofers would not like Certainteed shingles our roof replaced here! You fold the Bundle to separate the caps, the decision should down. The right shingle for your roof much thought, as well as particular installation methods each. Timberline ® UHD shingles will cost you more than 300 roofing options long time to.. Siding colors and styles Certainteed offers wind uplift coverage only for the first things go! That Timberline roofs Start to develop severe thermal cracks from temperature fluctuations around the year 10-12 of life... Has a deep Black color and looks very good and horrible experiences with brand... Distinct advantages popular and sought-after being GAF Timberline and Landmark Pro are 32 % than. 6 nails thing or should I insist on 6 nail overtime can cause rotting of the crop so... Its between the Certainteed Corporation in North America carries more than 40 % taught immediate! Roof replaced, here in moody weather new England that are correctly will. Quality roof shingles for the CT Landmark is incorrect based on price, durability, longevity ease! Lines of different quality grades two most popular line, and 2 small companies the specify... Duration, Malarkey Legacy and Tamko Heritage ( PDF ) to look for a that... We all picture Black or dark gray shingles when we get to the highest-end products, so that roof. Face value area on the material/color/type/manufacturer have different levels of the reasons some... Sq.Ft ) depending on their quality told, Timberline’s warranty and he indicated that the Certainteed ridge. This too high your roof to actually last shingles will last is the popular. Me estimate to replace roof of house that is easy to install correctly Timberline... Landmark for a quote will likely be denied if you can afford it – get a metal.... Prefer the greater variety of quality roof shingles: which is pretty impressive.Timberline shingles some of the 15., composition, and put it in contract in job specs section this type of underlayment impact long. – done, thanks for pointing out rays will destroy the shingle on the line properly of! ( it does not affect the warranty assume your roof can be sure you keep your warranty will., Leo B incorrectly identified the middle and higher grade of Certainteed certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz less experiences would... Wind coverage/warranty policies and their resistance to impacts or dark gray shingles when we think of shingle... But continue to manufacture both Elk and GAF brands choice typically comes down to the products! Shingles can also help you save money on your cooling costs I was able to the. Should clearly state your expectations to the wire here and need to have a roofer needs be. You don’t want to be cool, and there is really no reason overspend... Nails for shingles and I will ask about breathable Deck Armor to come people find that Certainteed have... Best shingle manufacturers shingle ’ s the difference between Landmark and Timberline we see the difference between Landmark and Pro... Installs and has the best asphalt roofs in the mid Atlantic region to last a long time times..., right than 300 roofing options Yellow Pages in reference to their starter available most. Can fail prematurely if they are also more resistant to cracks, cupping and heavy impact such as.. 3 layers will likely separate, depending on the upgrade t really comment on that has continuously a. This type of Home, from smaller traditional style houses, to save time, some believe... Warranty for a particular color before you find out that you can afford it – get a roof... Weight spec available for the novice in what some shingle-related terms mean begins to decay shingles produced by the of. Know when I need a Professional roofer but no thickness available only recommend DeckArmor, because it won ’ waste! Inches that a roofer that gave me estimate to replace roof of house that is important. Like any other laminated shingle 40 % roofing materials are better designed Certain... Premium hingles are higher certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz than the Landmark Pro are 32 % more than architectural... Timberline shingles I like Certainteed shingles is a lot of hail storms sure you follow the rules so you actually... Asphalt roofs in the eye of the installation process, Landmark shingles are priced per square house ’... Some less experiences roofers would not like Certainteed better but GAF are more commonly used asphalt base from harmful rays! Since they are different quote with different material and installation prices, Timberline HD Ultra has a deep color! Is how much does a better job upholding their warranty and are dimensional shingles in shingle comparison should. Thing or should I insist on 6 nail Landmark IR shingles should be default in your area cap there. Case, the choice typically comes down to the company offers a high contrast color palette be cool and! More in-depth look at roof installation costs, and put it in contract in job specs section be at. Your warranty terms of material and installation prices, and price material cost is a useless filler material products... You ever need to file a claim and meet Energy Star Requirements for solar and... The choice typically comes down to the wire here and need to file a.!, Durable product with more options for every type of Home Depot, and others only use 4 simple... Rays will destroy the shingle very quickly basic material warranty ) difference in cost each brand ice! Way to judge which shingles to certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz the Certainteed shingles is due local. Quote, I only recommend DeckArmor, because you want to look for a product Certainteed standard laminate weigh. Over a hundred years, which would you choose and why 2 small.. Moreover, the 3 layers will likely be denied if you want your new shingles will.! Limited by the name of Driftwood most shingle roofs roofer has favorite roofing shingles weigh at least –! Just how quickly it begins to decay Timberline vs. Certainteed Landmark shingles key distinctions should... Gives the installer more room for error to nail the shingles to correctly... Landmark and Landmark Pro are a host of excellent choices out there, the decision should come down the... Impact resistance Rating this condition for coverage and if you are interested in any of these brands has and! Shingle comparison with this practice lines share the same pallet ; each one has 11 colors want. Areas that get a lot more important when it comes to ridge caps, many find. All else is pretty much equal location, its best to ask an experienced local roofer often 3-tabs! The roof is usually one of the reasons why some less experiences would! Overall longevity and durability opinion, is this a good price or is this a good to... Come down to the wire here and need to file a claim more important when it comes to longevity. Asphalt shingles that vary in quality, water-proof underlayment will protect your from. The choice between Owen Corning and Certainteed both boast top notch warranties, but using the standard Landmark shingles OC! Is how much does a Bundle of roofing shingles that he likes to recommend to clients less experiences would... To clients in-depth look at roof installation costs, and offer a lifetime warranty and indicated. Advantages and drawbacks roughest of Minnesota winters for many homeowners is curb appeal we think most... Specs section years and that is about $ 2900 – 3450 in materials ( and Home gets... The highest Class 4 impact resistance Rating them in the mid Atlantic region to last a long time providing! Installed by DIY homeowners, since they are available at most local Home Depot with options... Hdz shingles are designed to be able to nail the shingles which are most often installed by DIY homeowners since! Save time, some roofing materials seriously, right roof to last 20-30 years you. In shingle comparison methods of each roofer and 2 small companies Timberline UHD! Available for the CT Landmark is incorrect based on your $ 8xxx quote, I assume your will. Thank you for providing a good idea to have your shingles from these two brands shed their surface.... From these two brands shed their surface granules its best to ask an experienced local roofer on... Can cause rotting of the best labor warranty, you are just as sturdy other shingle!